If a mother sells a house to her son, could it be considered a disguised gift?

If a mother sells a house to her son, could it be considered a disguised gift?
If a mother sells a house to her son, could it be considered a disguised gift?
Published on: by Rus María Muñoz Gómez

Table of contents

Yes, it can be, and that is what case law has established. Parents always want to help their children, but sometimes this leads to conflicts among heirs that end up in court. In this article, as expert inheritance lawyers, we analyze cases involving the transfer of assets from parents to children that may harm other children and be considered a disguised gift. 

Can you sell the bare ownership of a house to a child? 

Yes, but caution is required because it could be understood as a gift that harms the forced share of the rest of the children. 

Let's look at an example: a father decides to sell the bare ownership of the apartment where he lives to one of his children for a very low market price. In this way, the father retains the life usufruct of the house, meaning he can enjoy it until his death. This transaction is completely valid from a legal standpoint, but it can be considered a disguised gift if the market price is much higher than the agreed price. 

To avoid this problem, several steps can be taken: 

  • Set a price that reflects the actual market value. 
  • Request an appraisal from an independent appraiser. 
  • Provide proof of the payment made, for example, through a bank transfer receipt in favor of the parent. 

What happens if the sale affects the forced share of the rest of the children? 

In Spain, children are forced heirs, meaning they are entitled to receive a portion of the inheritance known as the forced share (legítima). If a parent sells an apartment to one of their children, it may be considered a collatable gift, meaning it must be accounted for in the estate. This happens if the value of the house sold to the child is much lower than the market value, as it can be deemed a disguised gift. 

In what cases can the rest of the children file a claim? 

If a parent sells a house to one of the siblings, the others may file a claim in several scenarios: 

  • If the sale is a disguised gift. For example, a purchase agreement is signed, but there is no actual payment of the price. 
  • If the children's forced share is harmed. The completed sale significantly reduces the forced share of the rest of the siblings. 
  • If there is any indication of a sham transaction. For example, the owner of the apartment—the parent—continues to act as the owner, living in the apartment and paying all expenses and taxes. 

Cases of selling a home to a child that turned out to be a disguised gift

A case recently occurred in Italy in which a mother sold the bare ownership of a home to her son and retained the usufruct of the apartment. In this case, the bare ownership had a market value much higher than what the son paid. The courts considered the sale to be a disguised gift because the home had been sold for less than half of its market value. In this case, the son had paid the agreed amount, but the difference between the market price and the price paid was too large, so it was understood to be a disguised gift. 

The Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court analyzed a similar case in 2012, in which it dismissed the cassation appeal and upheld the previous ruling issued by the Provincial Court of Madrid. In this case, in July 2001, a lawyer wanted to gift a single-family home in Torrelodones (Madrid) to his son, and to do so, they signed a purchase agreement between the father's company and his son's company. The Supreme Court held that it was evident that the two consents required by law for a gift were not recorded in the public deed. Therefore, it annulled the sale on the grounds that it disguised a gift. 

In what cases can you sell a house to a child when you have other children? 

It must be done in a way that does not constitute a disguised gift; therefore, the following elements must be present: 

  • The sale must be formalized and clearly regulated in a public deed before a notary. 
  • The ownership of the property must change so that the child clearly acts as the owner. 
  • There must be an actual payment; that is, the child must have the money to pay for the house or must apply for financing, and therefore, the transfer of funds must be documented. 

A gift could be added to the estate

If the transfer is considered not a sale but a gift, it may be understood as a collatable gift, which is one that an heir receives during their parent's lifetime, for example, and which must be taken into account at the time of receiving the inheritance. This prevents one child from receiving more than another and harming their forced share. 

For a collatable gift to exist, the recipient of the gift must be a forced heir and must inherit alongside other heirs.

Not every gift is collatable, as the deceased may have stipulated that the gift was simply a present with no obligation to offset it, or the heir may renounce their share of the inheritance. 

Collatable assets are those that forced heirs receive during the lifetime of the deceased through a gift, dowry, or other gratuitous benefit. 

Ultimately, caution must be exercised in these cases to avoid harming the rest of the children. 

If you need help making a will without harming any of your children, or if you are an heir and believe your inheritance has been harmed by a lifetime gift from your parent, contact our team of expert inheritance lawyers to analyze your case and advise you. 
 

A lawyer in less than 24 hours.
Lawyers - 24h A lawyer in less than 24 hours. We defend your interests
"Anywhere in Spain"

With our online appointment system you will have immediate advice without the need for face-to-face visits or travel.

One of our lawyers specialized in your area of interest will contact you to formalize an appointment and make your consultation by video call.

Available platforms

Add new comment

Do you need a lawyer in Madrid, we call you back

Fill in the form and we will call you as soon as possible.

* Required fields